The term civil society is another term not easily defined. Civil
society is a concept that is diverse, always changing, and controversial. In
the 1750’s a major shift occurred on the idea of what civil society was and
could be. Writers like Adam Ferguson and
Thomas Paine developed the idea of civil society saying it differed from the
state. Civil society was seen not only as a organization directed toward the
state but also having the ability to counter state powers. Over the past
hundreds of years scholars, philosophers, writers, and politicians have added
to the conversation of civil society and its benefits and drawbacks. By looking
at everyone’s ideas on civil society we can form a commonality of all their
interpretations.
Civil society is seen as its own sector. It consists of
mainly volunteers that maintain different objectives, interests, and
ideologies. These civil societies usually compete with each other. Lastly, they are viewed as freely
organized and interact with public sphere.
The status of MENA civil society is not a good status.
Although civil society has played large roles in democratic transitions all
over the world like Latin America and Eastern Europe, it hasn’t helped MENA
nearly at all. Many of NGO’s in MENA have been weakened and tamed. The civil
societies that exist usually have little impact and aren’t seen as a resource.
Civil society can play a big role in fostering political
participation in many countries around the world. We have seen it work but unfortunately
not in MENA. Although Morocco and Egypt had help from civil societies, by no
means did the play a huge role in their democratization. He states, “In Morocco
and Egypt, civil society has become a cause for some, a field to increase the
value of diplomas for others, or a practical notion and landmark for
international donors, journalists, diplomats, and academics. In none of these
countries should “real civil societies” be understood as the first step towards
democracy (Camau 2002)".
I kind of disagree with your point that social movements haven't facilitated the desire for democratic change in MENA. I think the protests of 2011-present are almost completely the result of social movements but have been crushed/"stolen"/unsuccessful because of the institutionalized state apparatuses they have come up against. Essentially the will is there, but the means are lacking.
ReplyDelete